Response: Statement from Nazarene church on Emergent

I mentioned earlier this week the recently released statement from the Board of General Superintendents on the relationship of the Church of the Nazarene to the “emergent” church.  I have linked here back to it if you’d like to read the specific statement.  Here are some of my reactions/thoughts to it:

1.  I’m glad they released this and talked about the need for “conversation” around this issue.  For a long time I’ve felt that there are many who feel that to even raise these issues would be seen as heretical and who were “secretly emergent” which usually lead to a parting of ways with the Nazarene church or even worse the church altogether.  We who believe that Christ is the truth should not be afraid of questions about the truth.

2.  While opening the door, this is a missed opportunity to truly embrace the missional aspect of the Nazarene church in its history, its foundation and perhaps its future.  Why not lean into the roots of the Nazarene church (not just Wesley) that have been trying to live and bring the gospel in all places?  Why not talk about the need to contextualize in this new culture/world, just as they embrace contextualizing “overseas” in mission?  Not only should we make room for this conversation, we should be leaning into it!

3.  The mention of diversity in the movement shows awareness and is important.  It helps keep it at a conversation level.  I really appreciate their attempt here to make room for Christian conversation and their awareness that the “conversation” has not been Christian too much.

4.  While I’m not 100% sure what is meant by “young Nazarenes”, why just “engage in conversations” with young Nazarenes?  Why not encourage, protect, embrace, resource? If this is a missional fit shouldn’t we be doing more than talking with them?  I guess I feel that just making room for conversation at this point is a help for some, but others are already doing new things, new ministry expressions that are attempting to be faithful to the heritage of Wesley and Nazarenes and also effectively engage the culture in love.  These ministries may appreciate the conversations, but they need more than words.  Can we protect them some how from those that are less than generous?  Can we call them brothers and sisters and treat them as such?

I’d love to hear your reactions…

Advertisements
This entry was posted in church, culture, emerging church, Jesus, Nazarene and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Response: Statement from Nazarene church on Emergent

  1. Brent Ragan says:

    In all of my years of travel and worship, the best sermon I ever heard was in an “emergent” church in San Diego.

  2. Tim Smith says:

    Brian,
    I resonate with your points. As I read it I too wondered why not mention our Nazarene roots.
    Your fourth point sits well: “Why not encourage, protect, embrace, resource? If this is a missional fit shouldn’t we be doing more than talking with them?”

    What has happened to the age old proverb – “Talk’s Cheap!”?

    • ragingbhull says:

      Thanks for the comment Tim!

      I recognize that statement was written in a context and it may well not have been one that included room to talk about some of these other things. However, I do think we’ve got to make room, not just for the conversation, but for embrace and encouragement. We try to control what we fear or do not understand. God help us to trust you and love each other!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s